‘I’m Certain No One Noticed This’ — Former Rockstar Developer Explains Tiny GTA 5 Detail You Might Have Missed
Everyone remembers Red Dead Redemption 2’s horse balls. When you’re riding your stallion down in temperate regions to the south, they’re normal balls. Horse balls, but normal ones. Go into the cold, snowblasted mountains in the north and they shrink, shriveling up like a prune on an L.A. driveway.
How does something seemingly so innocuous make it into a big Rockstar game? It’s partly because Rockstar lets its developers add little flourishes that players might not even notice, and partly because the company hires perfectionists. Designer Matt Freedman was one such perfectionist.
Freedman worked at Rockstar for almost nine years, starting as a level designer for Max Payne 3. His biggest job on GTA 5 was implementing the in-mission camera switching mechanic, which we delved into right here. But he also had a hand in something else in the game that you probably missed.
There’s a moment in GTA 5 where the player is introduced to playable character Trevor in a brutal way. He meets Johnny Klebitz, a protagonist from The Lost and the Damned DLC for GTA 4, and proceeds to stomp on his head until he’s not only dead, but unrecognizable. It’s a messy scene, and Freedman wanted to fully represent that in gameplay.
Freedman added a decal to Trevor’s jeans, blood spatter from the boot cuff up, as well as an algorithm that slowly made the blood fade and clean up over the course of a playthrough. Most players would never even notice, since this is a game where you can enter shops and customize the look of the characters. Most people would likely put Trevor into new clothes at the earliest opportunity. Freedman did it anyway.
“I like the players having a good time,” he said. “I take a lot of pride in my work. I always like to think that my real boss isn't like the guy who pays my paycheck. It's the guy who pays that guy's paycheck, and that's the player. So I'm always like, look, if you're coming home from a s***ty day at work, you know things are rough, you're having a hard time making ends meet. You sit down, you boot up a game I've worked on, I just want you to have a really good time.
“I spend a lot of time just being like, look at like, is this a potentially reasonable thing for the player to want to do? And is the game respecting the player's choices? I spent a lot of extra cycles on Max Payne 3 just making sure that if the player had performed a gameplay interaction at some point in the level, that would be respected consistently across the level.”
For Trevor’s bloody jean cuff, it was more work than you might realize. As well as creating the rules and algorithm for slowly cleaning the jeans up, Freedman had to make sure it stayed at the exact same point of the clean up whenever the character respawned, which basically creates a fresh version of the model each time. Notice how your bruises and cuts disappear when you die? That wouldn’t do for the bloody jean leg.
“I'm certain no one noticed this,” Freedman laughed. “In video games it's really important for people to feel that their choices and effort are respected, that the time is being respected. That's one of the great things I think with Nintendo's design is that they do such a wonderful job of making interactive and responsive worlds.”
Things like this are what sets Rockstar apart. Horse balls are an easy one to laugh at, but that’s because it’s such a ridiculous example of the level of detail the company’s developers strive for. It’s why people come back to Rockstar’s games every time — whether it’s Red Dead Redemption or GTA, there’s a certain level of quality and competence guaranteed that no other developer on the planet has either the resources or ability to achieve.
Players might not notice this stuff at launch, but there’s a reason I’m writing about it right now all these years later. Discovery is such a huge part of the appeal of video games. We live in a world where sometimes it feels like it’s all been done before. There are no new lands to discover, we’ve shot people into space, but we can satiate that primal drive to find new horizons through horse balls and bloody jean legs.
GTA 6 is expected to be the biggest entertainment launch of all time, and some companies have even given staff bonus time off to play it. We've got plenty more on GTA 6 ahead of its November 19 launch, including details on the New Zealand trick people are using to play early, Gangland Tales From the Frontline of Rockstar's Real-Life Grand Theft Auto Research, and How Gaming's Top Content Creators Are Preparing for GTA 6's Launch and Beyond.